Surprising Reasons that You Might Pay More for Car Insurance

Lisa Broadbent • March 4, 2024
Man in a suit holding car keys, standing next to a blue car in a city setting.

High risk drivers are likely to pay more for their auto insurance because they are more likely to cost the insurer a lot of money. 


Insurers calculate your risk rating based on how likely you are to file a claim and how much that claim is likely to cost them. Your risk level is based on a variety of factors, and the higher risk you pose, the higher premiums you may pay. After all, the riskier and more expensive you are to insure, the more your insurer is likely to charge you. 


If you ever get a ticket, have an at-fault accident or increase your car insurance policy’s limits, then you should not be shocked to see your car insurance premiums go up. However, there are a lot of other reasons that your auto insurer might increase your premiums. Some of them might surprise you. 


Let’s take a closer look at some of the more surprising reasons that your car insurance premium might rise, and what you can do to help stabilize your rates. 


You Are Getting Older 


Age is a factor that can influence car insurance rates. One of the most obvious examples of this phenomenon is when a teen driver pays a much higher premium for their car insurance than their sibling who is in their 20’s. A teen driver has very little experience behind the wheel compared to seasoned drivers. Therefore, they are much more likely to have a wreck. 


However, old age is also a factor that could drive up your rates. Even though you have a lot of experience driving, you might no longer be as spry as you once were. Reflexes, eyesight and reaction time all help you drive safely. As you get older and these faculties slow down a bit, your risk of a wreck might go up. Therefore, this factor might drive your rates. 


You Move to a Busier Area 


In some communities the risks of car wrecks, vehicle theft or other losses are very high. For example, if you move from a small town to a large city, then there is a lot more traffic on the road around you. There are also higher risks of vehicle theft and other property crimes. As a result, you have a higher risk of having to file a claim on your policy. Therefore, you might have to pay more for your plan. 


You are Single 


Some studies suggest that married people are better drivers than single individuals. Therefore, some insurance companies will charge a single driver more than a married one (all else being equal). 


Plus, single drivers who only need to insure one car often do not qualify for multi-car insurance policies. Comparatively speaking, families might save money through a multi-vehicle plan option as opposed to insuring all the drivers and cars in their households under separate plans. Still, not all insurers will charge you more just because you are single. 


You are a Loyal Customer 


If you have stayed with the same insurance company for numerous years, then you might pay a higher rate than someone who just joined that company. This surprises many drivers, since a lot of insurance companies reward discounts to those who have stayed loyal to them over the years. 


However, some insurers offer lower rates to customers who have a history of changing companies frequently. They might do so to maintain those clients’ business and remain competitive in the market. Some consumer protection groups even have found that certain insurers will take the risk of raising a loyal customer’s rates because they know that person is likely going to remain a customer. 


You Have a Lower Level of Education 


If you have not finished college, then you might pay more for your car insurance. While it is hard to determine exactly what causes these higher rates, one reason might be financial. 


Those without college degrees tend to make less money than those with more professional training. As a result, they might not have the financial reserves available to pay for the costs of accidents out of pocket. Therefore, they might be more likely to file a claim against their car insurance for a vehicle loss. 


A higher reliance on car insurance claims, therefore, could drive up someone’s rates. This is particularly true because insurers often look at someone’s history of filing claims when developing quotes. If they see that you have made a lot of claims in the past, then they might guess that you have a higher risk of filing another one in the future. Therefore, you might have to pay more. 


What’s important to remember, however, is that no single factor is going to be a make-or-break deal in increasing or decreasing your car insurance premiums. Instead, the combination of numerous factors will play the deciding role. The best thing to do to ensure that you get affordable rates is to talk to an independent insurance agent. They can help you compare the policy offerings of numerous carriers to find the plan that offers you the best affordability. 


Contact an agent at Broadbent Insurance (302) 731-0044 today to discuss your auto insurance options and allow us to give you an estimate on the coverage that is best for you and your family.


Businessperson shielding a glowing car icon, symbolizing auto insurance protection.
By Lisa Broadbent Insurance • October 20, 2026
Shopping for auto insurance quotes in Middletown, DE? Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. compares carriers to find your best fit. Call (302) 731-0044 today.
Person signing auto insurance documents beside model car and protection shield.
By Lisa Broadbent Insurance • October 20, 2026
Learn Delaware's 2026 auto insurance policy rules for Middletown drivers. Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. offers custom coverage. Call (302) 731-0044 today.
Agent and client discussing an auto insurance policy claim with toy cars in a collision
By Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. • September 25, 2026
Understand your auto insurance policy in Middletown, DE. Lisa Broadbent Insurance covers DE minimums, PIP, and lapse penalties. Get a local quote today.
Depiction of a situation related to a car collision or insurance claim
June 30, 2026
Automobile insurance in Hockessin, DE, can shield you from repair bills, medical costs, and liability claims. Call Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. to find the right coverage today.
Hands using a pen and calculator over a clipboard with a blue toy car, suggesting auto insurance paperwork
April 27, 2026
Avoid costly mistakes in automobile insurance with Broadbent Insurance, Inc. Serving Hockessin, DE, drivers. Click here for the best advice and coverage tips!
Finger pressing a car insurance start button on a dashboard.
April 13, 2026
Need commercial vehicle insurance in Hockessin, DE? Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. can help protect your business. Call us at 302-731-0044 today.
Icicles hanging from a snow-covered roof of a brick building with white shutters.
By Lisa Broadbent • January 5, 2026
Taking precautions to prevent ice dams is an important part of preparing your home for winter weather. Knowing what an ice dam is , minimizing the conditions that allow one to form and removing an ice dam as soon as you spot one can help prevent serious damage to both the roof and the inside of your home. Take action before snow starts falling An ice dam may develop during the cold winter months if warm air from your home or attic melts snow on your roof. In freezing temperatures, the melted snow may refreeze once it reaches the colder edge of the roof. Keeping the temperature of your attic at 32°F or below can help prevent snow from melting and ice dams from developing. The following are some steps you can take to help prevent the snow melting-and-freezing cycle that often causes ice dams: Insulate your attic. Be sure your attic is properly insulated to help prevent warmth from escaping through ceilings. Whenever possible, an insulation value of R-40 is recommended. Prevent air leaks. Check and seal any openings where warm air or heat could escape into the attic, such as insulating or caulking around vent pipes, exhaust fans, chimneys, attic hatches and/or light fixtures. Improve ventilation. Increase the number or size of attic, roof or soffit vents that allow cold air to circulate and flush warmer air out during the winter. Install a water-repellent membrane. When replacing the roof covering, install a water-repellent membrane underneath the shingles. This acts as an extra barrier that helps prevent water from seeping inside the building should an ice dam form. Tips to help prevent ice dams through the winter Ice dams can sometimes form despite your best efforts to keep your roof at the proper temperature. Be sure to monitor the weather and maintain your roof throughout the colder winter months for additional protection against ice dams, such as: Clear gutters and downspouts. Prevent water from accumulating and possibly freezing in your gutters by cleaning leaves, debris and snow accumulation from in and around gutters and downspouts. Making sure that your gutters are properly pitched can also help prevent the collection of water in low spots and help reduce the potential for ice buildup in gutters. Remove snow accumulation from your roof after every storm. Whenever possible, use a roof rake to clear snow about three to four feet from the edge of your roof soon after each storm. Snow accumulation along the edge of your roof increases the likelihood of an ice dam developing, which prevents water from draining off the roof. This water can then back up underneath roof shingles and make its way into your home. Remove ice dams as soon as you spot them. Check your roof often and know how to help identify and remove an ice dam. CAUTION: Avoid using a ladder in snowy and icy conditions. This can be extremely dangerous and is best left to the professionals. For questions or concerns about insurance to protect your home’s roof, please contact us at 302-731-0044 , or email lisa@broadbentins.com . Our agents and staff are available Monday-Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET, with the exception of holidays.
Hands forming a protective gesture over a wooden car model placed on an insurance document.
November 27, 2025
Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc., in Hockessin explains why your auto insurance policy needs a yearly review. Call 302-731-0044 or click here to learn more.
A businessman covering a toy car with his hands, symbolizing auto insurance protection and care.
November 4, 2025
Discover trusted auto insurance in Hockessin from Lisa Broadbent Insurance Inc. Contact 302-731-0044 for expert and professional local coverage today!
A tree fell onto a two-story yellow house after a storm.
By Lisa Broadbent • July 18, 2025
Check your hurricane insurance coverage today.
Show More