Rental Car Insurance Coverage - Do You Really Need It?

Lisa Broadbent • August 1, 2022
Person handing car keys to another person in a car.

You’ve stepped off the plane, collected your bags and are headed over to the car rental desk. Only a few signatures and a credit card swipe stand between you and the open road.

As you’re sorting through pages of policy acknowledgments, the inevitable question comes from across the desk: Would you like to purchase additional daily rental insurance? With rental car rates getting steeper by the day, you may be wondering whether it’s necessary to bump up your bill any higher than it already is.


It goes without saying that purchasing insurance is the responsible and prudent way to minimize unforeseen losses. That’s why, in nearly every scenario, you should jump at the opportunity to buy more coverage. But is there ever a time when more becomes too much?

Rental car insurance is a prime example of overprotection and paying for coverage that you very likely already have. Paying over $10 a day for rental car insurance may seem like a smart decision, but before you make up your mind, let’s break things down:


Step 1: Before accepting any new coverage from a car rental company, it’s critical that you first review the insurance policies you have. You may not know it, but there’s a high probability you’re already insured if an accident occurs in your rental car.

Personal Auto-Policy: The liability coverage you have on your policy as well as any additional coverage you’ve purchased should be applicable to a rental car if you’re driving it for personal use.


  • Existing liability coverage would help you pay for others’ medical bills, as well as damage to others’ property in an accident where you’re at fault.
  • Existing comprehensive coverage would help to pay for repairs to your rental in the event of theft, fire and natural disasters.
  • Existing collision coverage would help pay for the repairs to a rental car if damaged when crashing into another vehicle or physical object.

    Your Credit Card Company: According to the Insurance Information Institute , if you pay for a car rental using a certain credit card, there’s a chance that they will provide “secondary” insurance. This means that anything your primary insurer doesn’t cover from a personal auto-policy will be covered by the credit card company. This may include deductibles and expenses that exceed a coverage limit.

    • Keep in mind, however, that certain rental vehicles are not be covered by most credit cards. These include luxury vehicles, motorhomes, trucks and motorcycles.

      Step 2 : After reviewing the coverage you already possess, that expensive daily policy offered by rental companies probably isn’t looking appealing. However, there are cases when this insurance may be beneficial.

      • Your primary and secondary policy is limited in coverage or has exclusions (ex. it doesn’t have comprehensive or collision coverage, which is offered by the rental company).
      • You’re only insured under a commercial car insurance policy.
      • You’re driving outside of the country (besides Canada, most primary insurers and credit card companies won’t cover you for accidents outside the U.S.).

      Step 3: No matter which policy you choose, you’ll never receive coverage for reckless behavior. Always remain extra vigilant when using a rental car – that means avoiding certain surfaces, being aware of its condition (locked, where it’s parked, etc.), and never driving while intoxicated. Safe driving is always in the best interest of your insurers, your passengers, and yourself.


      If you have questions about car rental insurance coverage, please call Lisa Broadbent Insurance at (302) 731-0044 today and we’ll help you determine if you have the right coverage for all of your auto insurance needs.


      Hands using a pen and calculator over a clipboard with a blue toy car, suggesting auto insurance paperwork
      April 27, 2026
      Avoid costly mistakes in automobile insurance with Broadbent Insurance, Inc. Serving Hockessin, DE, drivers. Click here for the best advice and coverage tips!
      Finger pressing a car insurance start button on a dashboard.
      April 13, 2026
      Need commercial vehicle insurance in Hockessin, DE? Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc. can help protect your business. Call us at 302-731-0044 today.
      Icicles hanging from a snow-covered roof of a brick building with white shutters.
      By Lisa Broadbent January 5, 2026
      Taking precautions to prevent ice dams is an important part of preparing your home for winter weather. Knowing what an ice dam is , minimizing the conditions that allow one to form and removing an ice dam as soon as you spot one can help prevent serious damage to both the roof and the inside of your home. Take action before snow starts falling An ice dam may develop during the cold winter months if warm air from your home or attic melts snow on your roof. In freezing temperatures, the melted snow may refreeze once it reaches the colder edge of the roof. Keeping the temperature of your attic at 32°F or below can help prevent snow from melting and ice dams from developing. The following are some steps you can take to help prevent the snow melting-and-freezing cycle that often causes ice dams: Insulate your attic. Be sure your attic is properly insulated to help prevent warmth from escaping through ceilings. Whenever possible, an insulation value of R-40 is recommended. Prevent air leaks. Check and seal any openings where warm air or heat could escape into the attic, such as insulating or caulking around vent pipes, exhaust fans, chimneys, attic hatches and/or light fixtures. Improve ventilation. Increase the number or size of attic, roof or soffit vents that allow cold air to circulate and flush warmer air out during the winter. Install a water-repellent membrane. When replacing the roof covering, install a water-repellent membrane underneath the shingles. This acts as an extra barrier that helps prevent water from seeping inside the building should an ice dam form. Tips to help prevent ice dams through the winter Ice dams can sometimes form despite your best efforts to keep your roof at the proper temperature. Be sure to monitor the weather and maintain your roof throughout the colder winter months for additional protection against ice dams, such as: Clear gutters and downspouts. Prevent water from accumulating and possibly freezing in your gutters by cleaning leaves, debris and snow accumulation from in and around gutters and downspouts. Making sure that your gutters are properly pitched can also help prevent the collection of water in low spots and help reduce the potential for ice buildup in gutters. Remove snow accumulation from your roof after every storm. Whenever possible, use a roof rake to clear snow about three to four feet from the edge of your roof soon after each storm. Snow accumulation along the edge of your roof increases the likelihood of an ice dam developing, which prevents water from draining off the roof. This water can then back up underneath roof shingles and make its way into your home. Remove ice dams as soon as you spot them. Check your roof often and know how to help identify and remove an ice dam. CAUTION: Avoid using a ladder in snowy and icy conditions. This can be extremely dangerous and is best left to the professionals. For questions or concerns about insurance to protect your home’s roof, please contact us at 302-731-0044 , or email lisa@broadbentins.com . Our agents and staff are available Monday-Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET, with the exception of holidays.
      Hands forming a protective gesture over a wooden car model placed on an insurance document.
      November 27, 2025
      Lisa Broadbent Insurance, Inc., in Hockessin explains why your auto insurance policy needs a yearly review. Call 302-731-0044 or click here to learn more.
      A businessman covering a toy car with his hands, symbolizing auto insurance protection and care.
      November 4, 2025
      Discover trusted auto insurance in Hockessin from Lisa Broadbent Insurance Inc. Contact 302-731-0044 for expert and professional local coverage today!
      A tree fell onto a two-story yellow house after a storm.
      By Lisa Broadbent July 18, 2025
      Check your hurricane insurance coverage today.
      House flooded with brown water, surrounded by trees, on an overcast day.
      By Lisa Broadbent June 6, 2025
      Why aren't homeowners buying flood insurance? They may believe one of these myths.
      Woman in a navy blue sequined dress with a corsage on her wrist, at a formal event.
      By Lisa Broadbent February 8, 2025
      The Dress, The Date, The Hair, The Music, and what to do after… all things that are on your teen's mind before the infamous prom night. Driving is usually not an important component in a teen's mind, but for parents it can be a big worry. Many parents often overlook the need to have honest discussions with their teens about safe driving and avoiding alcohol and drugs. Statistics show that prom and graduation season—the months of April, May and June—are the most dangerous time for teens. One-third of the alcohol-related traffic fatalities involving teens each year occur during those months. Here's an honest and teen-friendly guide to sharing concerns with your teen for one of the most important nights of their adolescent career. Many parents often overlook the need to have honest discussions with their teens about safe driving and avoiding alcohol and drugs. Have a good time. Explain to your teen that you want them to have fun and enjoy themselves. Just don't drink. Years from now, they will laugh when looking back at prom, but not if they don't remember the night. Relate it to your prom. Explain to them what you did right or wrong and what the consequences were. Don't be afraid to tell them the truth if you made some bad judgment calls. This can only help them to feel that you are human and that you regret those decisions and don't want them to make the same. Remind them of their future. High school is a great time, but they have their whole future ahead of them. Don't ruin that by drinking or doing drugs on Prom night or any night. Immature vs. Mature. Your teen may think that drinking or doing drugs and driving is what the grown-up thing is to do. Explain to them that is the most immature and irresponsible decision they could make. Being mature is about making the right decision and keeping your future in sight. Drive safe! If they are driving, make sure that they understand the responsibility of driving on Prom night. Share these six tips with your teen: Wear seatbelts. Don't speed. Be a defensive driver. Not everyone on the road is going to be as safe as you, watch out for other unsafe drivers. Don't drink or do drugs. This impairs judgment for driving and could potentially end in a fatality. If you do make a mistake, or find yourself in an uncomfortable situation, call your parents immediately. They will respect you for being mature enough to see the danger and making the right call. Don't ride with anyone who has been drinking or doing drugs. This takes your life out of your hands. Pay attention to the road while driving. Don't get distracted with cell phones, radio, or passengers. Driving is a very important responsibility and shouldn't be taken lightly. Teenage drivers have the highest crash risk of any age group and it's largely due to driver error. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, one in four crash fatalities involve someone 16 to 24 years old, nearly twice as high as other age groups. Don't let your teenager be a statistic. Talk with your teen and communicate the importance of safe driving on Prom night and every night. Your safety is number one to us. If you want to make sure you have the right insurance coverage for your teen driver, you can contact the insurance team at Lisa Broadbent Insurance at (302) 731-0044 today to get an evaluation and free quote. Stay safe wherever you choose to go on the road.
      Driver's view through windshield of a car, snowy road, approaching two arch bridges, flanked by snow-covered trees.
      By Lisa Broadbant January 8, 2025
      Stay safe on the roads this winter with essential driving tips from Broadbent Insurance. Learn how to prepare your vehicle and drive confidently in snowy conditions.
      Deer in headlights, crossing road at night, viewed from inside a car.
      By Lisa Broadbent December 3, 2024
      Learn practical tips on how to avoid hitting a deer and ensure your safety on the road. Broadbent Insurance provides essential advice for drivers.
      Show More